All-Time Scholar-Athlete Winners
| MEN'S SPORTS | WOMEN'S SPORTS | ||||||
| Year | Name | School | Sport | Name | School | Sport | |
| 2025 | Ian Mowad | Palomar | Baseball | Rhiannon Walker | Clovis | Cross Country/Track & Field | |
| 2024 | James Bose | West Valley | Baseball | Mia Park | El Camino | Swim & Dive | |
| 2023 | Dante Jackson | Butte | Football | Kylie Gallick | Ventura | Basketball | |
| 2022 | Cameron Barry | San Diego Miramar | Basketball | Savannah Wahl | Butte | Softball | |
| 2021 | Not selected due to pandemic | Not selected due to pandemic | |||||
| 2020 | Nathan Clark | Ohlone | Water Polo/Swim & Dive | Tess Oakley-Stinson | Glendale | Basketball | |
| 2019 | Aaron Thomas | El Camino | Football | Brandy Huffhines | Sacramento City | Basketball | |
| 2018 | William Zurcher | College of Marin | Baseball | Janelle McAfee | West Valley | Softball | |
| 2017 | Apefa'I Taifane | West Hills Coalinga | Football | Breanne Dubberke | Fresno City | Volleyball | |
| 2016 | Evan May | Long Beach City | Baseball | Danielle Scelsi | Saddleback | Soccer | |
| 2015 | Anthony Berkovatz | Sacramento City | Football | Kelly Wong | San Francisco | Basketball | |
| 2014 | Albert Gamez, Jr. | San Diego Mesa | Cross Country/Track & Field | Brianna Massey | West Valley | Softball | |
| 2013 | Daniel Sayles | Sacramento City | Baseball | Hanna Burge | Ventura | Basketball | |
| 2012 | Malte Kramer | Cuesta | Basketball | Kelly Huey | Skyline | Basketball | |
| 2011 | David Pennington | Bakersfield | Baseball | Nicole Gummersall | Taft | Volleyball | |
| 2010 | Justin Bricker | Oxnard | Baseball | Michelle Lopez | Los Medanos | Soccer | |
| 2009 | Joshua Lee Denz | San Diego Mesa | Water Polo/Swim & Dive | Rachael Johnson | Solano | Soccer | |
| 2008 | Diego Martinez | Rio Hondo | Wrestling | Sonia Gutierrez | Cerritos | Tennis | |
| 2007 | Ziad Al-Helew | West Valley | Football | Viridiana Martino | Southwestern | Tennis | |
| 2006 | Jonathon Falcioni | Chaffey | Swim & Dive | Mary Hanley | Moorpark | Track & Field | |
| 2005 | David Lainhart | West Hills Coalinga | Basketball | Melissa Ulrich | Shasta | Swim & Dive | |
| 2004 | Mazimilian Zavodny | Palomar | Cross Country/Swim & Dive | Marisa Parker | Butte | Track & Field | |
| 2003 | Jeremy Waldram | Cuesta | Wrestling | Kathryn Swart | Taft | Volleyball | |
| 2002 | Kris Shirley | Palomar | Wrestling | Tia De Soto | Santa Rosa | Track & Field | |
| 2001 | Chameion Sutton | Butte | Football | Aliah Abdo | De Anza | Volleyball/Track & Field | |
| 2000 | Joe Hatke | Cuesta | Swim & Dive | Cherise Meichtry | Moorpark | Volleyball | |
| 1999 | Ryan Heitmann | Taft | Baseball | Rebecca Lane | Santa Barbara City | Basketball/Softball | |
| 1998 | Charles Cooke | Antelope Valley | Baseball | Aileen Bennett | Orange Coast | Water Polo /Swim & Dive | |
| 1997 | Tyler Garratt | Foothill | Basketball | Gabriela Reyes | Cypress | Basketball | |
| 1996 | Charles Malki | Saddleback | Swim & Dive | Yvonne Goodson | Feather River | Volleyball/Basketball | |
| 1995 | Devin Kendall | Laney | Football | Kristin Loedrup | Siskiyous | Track & Field | |
| 1994 | Shawn Young | Fresno City | Cross Country/Track & Field | Holly Rohne | American River | Cross Country/Track & Field | |
| 1993 | Lance Berger | Sacramento City | Baseball | Alexis Ash | Bakersfield | Track & Field | |
| 1992 | Pieter d'Arnaud | San Diego Mesa | Cross Country/Track & Field | Jennifer Kocek | Desert | Tennis | |
| 1991 | Carlos Fernandez | Golden West | Water Polo/Swim & Dive | Yoky Matsuoka | Santa Barbara City | Tennis | |
| 1990 | Erik Bonnar | Cerritos | Water Polo/Swim & Dive | Pamela Boyles | Bakersfield | Track & Field | |
| 1989 | Pablo Brescia | Oxnard | Soccer | Julie Lienert | American River | Basketball | |
| Dave Rice | Mt. San Antonio | Basketball | |||||
| 1988 | Kipp Penovich | Chaffey | Basketball | Laura Bonsness | Porterville | Cross Country | |
| 1987 | Kevin Curtis | Antelope Valley | Football | Eileen M. Ebineer | Mt. San Antonio | Cross Country/Track & Field | |
| 1986 | Benjamin "Tracy" Hunt | Shasta | Track & Field | Lih-Jiau Hendry | Desert | Track & Field | |
| Lisa Sweeney | Golden West | Swim & Dive | |||||
| 1985 | James Ferriera | El Camino | Track & Field | Lisa Burrows | Redwoods | Basketball | |
| 1984 | Frank Klopp III | San Diego Mesa | Baseball | Angela Bushling | Yuba | Cross Country/Track & Field | |